Four scores, all public data
Every tool is scored on four things anyone can check, from dated public data. Stephanie’s picks appear separately and have no effect on any score.
40%
User ratings
What people who use it rate it, weighted by how many reviews each site has. Under 25 public reviews, there’s no score at all.
Source: G2 (counted once for its family of sites), the Chrome Web Store and the app stores. Checked monthly.
25%
Popularity
How many people use it, and how fast that’s growing: website traffic, total reviews, and how fast new reviews are coming in compared with a dated snapshot.
Source: Tranco traffic rank, public review counts, and Internet Archive snapshots. Checked monthly.
20%
Best‑of lists
How current, independent best-of lists rank it. Being named adds; not being named doesn’t subtract, because no one can read every list in full. Lists published by companies that sell what they rank never count.
Source: every list we track, checked monthly for its date, its picks and its owner.
15%
Value
What a year really costs, whether the free version gives you something usable, and whether a cheap trial renews every 4 weeks. For hiring software: whether the price is public at all.
Source: vendor pricing pages, saved to the Internet Archive every month.
The weights only set the order of the list. Every review shows all four scores, so you can weigh them your own way. When a category has no data for one score yet, the others share its weight.
The research behind it
Our scoring copies what the most trusted review sites and researchers already do. We kept the parts that hold up and fixed the parts that let vendors in.
See the research, source by source
| What the research shows | How we use it |
|---|---|
| G2 places software on two measures, user satisfaction and market presence, and its Grid placement can't be changed by hand. G2 research scoring methodologies | Our user and popularity scores mirror those two measures, and no one can adjust a score or a rank by hand. |
| Capterra's Shortlist scores each product half on user ratings from the last 12 months and half on popularity. Capterra Shortlist methodology | Same two pillars. We weight users above popularity (40% to 25%) because popularity rewards whoever has been around longest. |
| G2 counts a review about 3% less for every month it ages, and TrustRadius weights newer reviews more and gives extra weight to reviews collected independently of vendors. G2 research guidelines; TrustRadius scoring FAQ | We re-check every rating monthly and count review growth in the popularity score. Lists published by companies that sell what they rank never count. |
| IMDb's published weighted rating pulls titles with few votes toward the overall average, so a handful of votes can't outrank thousands. IMDb help center | Our users score uses the same adjustment: a tool with 37 reviews moves a little toward the category average; one with 3,200 barely moves. Below 25 reviews there is no score at all. |
| Northwestern's Spiegel Research Center found purchase likelihood peaks at 4.2 to 4.5 stars and falls as ratings near a perfect 5, and that five reviews make a purchase 270% more likely than none. Spiegel Research Center, Northwestern University | We always print the review count next to a rating. A wall of perfect scores makes us look closer. |
| Reviewers who get something in return rate the same products about 0.4 to 0.5 stars higher, and disclosing the incentive doesn't remove the bias. University of Florida, Warrington College of Business | Where a source labels reviews as incentivized or vendor-invited, we record the share and show it next to the rating. |
| Consumer Reports builds its overall scores from tests and owner surveys, and a product earns its Recommended label through those scores. Consumer Reports | Our labels like Top-rated checker and Small teams pick are earned the same way: they go to the top data score in their group, automatically. |
| Wirecutter's picks are editorial judgments, kept independent of affiliate deals and advertising. Wirecutter, The New York Times | Stephanie's picks work like Wirecutter's: a named person's judgment, labeled as hers, and kept apart from the scores. |
What we can’t do yet. Most sources publish only an average rating, without each review's date, so we can't yet discount older reviews the way G2 does. Where a source offers a last-12-months rating, we use it. Independent lists for applicant tracking systems aren't tracked yet, so those scores use user ratings, popularity and value, which share the best-of lists weight.
Where Stephanie’s judgment comes in
Stephanie has twenty years in talent acquisition. Her opinion is always labeled and never changes a score.
What she does
- Names her picks, one for job seekers and one for hiring teams, labeled as hers.
- Nominates tools to check, so a good one doesn't have to wait for a marketing budget to get noticed.
- Writes the guidance: what a recruiter sees when your resume lands, how to use a tool and what to watch out for.
- Chooses the people worth following.
What she never does
- Sets or edits a score.
- Moves a tool up or down a ranking.
- Changes a weight for one tool or one category.
- Accepts money, gifts or deals for any of the above.
Stephanie also built RepVera. It’s listed on this site in its own category, verified professional reputation, with no score and no rank, and nothing in that category is scored or ranked. Who pays for this site
How we pick a tool for you
Pick what you’re dealing with. We’ll show you the best match and a couple of alternatives, and tell you what we ruled out. Try it.
| The rule | What it means |
|---|---|
| Start with what’s going wrong. | The right tool depends on the problem you’re trying to fix. |
| Sometimes the answer is no tool. | When software won’t fix it, we say so and point you to what will. |
| Your answers cross tools off, and they never change a rating. | A tool fits everything you asked for or it’s out, and we show you why. The tools that fit stay in rating order, the same for everyone. |
| If we can’t confirm it, we don’t recommend it. | A tool we can’t confirm meets your needs can’t be in your answer. It’s listed under what we ruled out, with what we couldn’t confirm. |
| You get the best match and up to two alternatives. | The best match is the top-rated tool that fits. Each alternative carries one label: best free option, most complete, or Stephanie’s pick, and her pick never changes a score. When none of those applies, the next-highest rated tool that fits is the backup. Every tool we left out is listed with the reason. |
| Only rated tools can be the best match. | Tools too new to rate stay on our watch list, labeled that way. |
| Show what you’ll really pay. | The cheapest way to pay for your timeline, and what it costs if you forget to cancel. |
| If nothing fits, say so, and show the closest tool and what’s in the way. | |
| Commissions never change the answer. | Whether we earn anything from a tool plays no part in any answer. |
| Same situation, same answer. | Every answer has its own link and a date, so you can share it. |
See the research behind these rules
| The research | What it shows, and how we use it |
|---|---|
| Why one deal-breaker rules a tool out Tversky, A. (1972). Elimination by aspects: A theory of choice. Psychological Review, 79, 281-299. | Psychologist Amos Tversky found that people choose by picking one thing that matters, crossing off every option that fails it, and repeating until one is left. Being great at one thing can’t make up for failing another. Your answers work the same way: a tool that misses one is out, however good it is at something else. |
| Why you get a short kit instead of a ranked list Chernev, A., Bockenholt, U., and Goodman, J. (2015). Choice overload: A conceptual review and meta-analysis. Journal of Consumer Psychology, 25(2), 333-358. | Pooling 99 results from earlier studies, researchers found that more options leave people less satisfied and less sure of their choice when the choice is complicated, the decision is hard, they aren’t sure what they want, and they want it done quickly. A job search or a hiring crunch hits all four, so the answer is the best match and a couple of alternatives instead of a ranked list of ten. |
Where the numbers come from
Every score on this site is assembled from sources you can check. Here’s where each one comes from.
See each source
Named platforms are sources of public data. None are affiliated with or endorse this site.
Do the other reviewers agree?
Every guide shows where each tool lands on the other lists you are likely to read, next to where we land. When we disagree with another list, we explain why.
Current, independent lists land where we land. Our numbers and the other reviewers point the same way.
We rank it somewhere the other lists don’t, higher or lower, and the review says exactly why. Usually it’s the users or the price telling a different story than the lists.
There aren’t enough public reviews or current lists for anyone to rank it, including us, so it stays unranked.
Which lists count. A list counts when it was updated in the last 12 months and its publisher doesn’t sell what it ranks. We still show the rest, with the reason.
What it looks like on a review
Every review shows the scores, what the review is based on, and when we last checked each number.
Best for teams hiring under 50 people a year
How these scores are calculated ↗Every review says what it’s based on
The vendor walked us through the live product and answered our standard questions. The most complete kind of review.
The vendor filled in our written questions: pricing, features, who it’s for, product materials.
Built from the vendor’s help pages, pricing pages, public reviews and traffic data. The vendor hasn’t talked to us yet.
How we find new tools
A great tool shouldn’t need a marketing budget to get noticed. If it shows up in any one of these places, we check it within a month: reviews counted, lists read, category recorded.
See every way a tool gets checked
| If a tool is… | What happens |
|---|---|
| Named on a current, independent best-of list | One list puts it in the queue. Two make it a contender. |
| Top 10 by review count in its G2 category, or by users in its Chrome Web Store category | Checked for every category we cover and every category in research. |
| Review count up 50% or more in a year | Measured from Internet Archive snapshots, the same way we caught Manatal's rise. |
| Stephanie nominates it | Her 20 years in hiring help find tools worth checking. A nomination gets a tool checked and has no effect on its score. |
| Recruiters recommend it in the communities we read | Recruiting Brainfood, RecruitingDaily, SourceCon and r/recruiting. Discovery only: none of these feed a score. |
| People search for it | If people are searching "is X worth it" or "X vs Y", we owe them a check. |
| Employers ask for it by name in job postings | Hiring tools only. "Experience with X" in a posting means real teams run it. |
| Listed in the integration marketplace of an ATS we rank | Teams don't integrate tools they don't use. |
| Readers ask for it | Anyone can nominate a tool. Every request is logged. |
| The vendor submits it | Listing is free. Submitting gets a tool checked, never scored higher. |
Follower counts don’t count. They measure marketing reach and tell you nothing about whether the product works. Followers can be bought, they swell with job posts and founders' personal brands, and LinkedIn's terms bar collecting them at scale. A sudden jump can prompt a check. It never moves a score.
Discovery puts a tool in the queue. Only public data (user ratings, popularity, best-of lists and value) moves a score. Know a tool we missed? Tell us.
Short lists
Some categories are too new to score. For those we publish a short list with no scores, and we say so at the top of the page. A category moves to scored rankings once there is enough public data.
We check everything monthly
We check every review on the same schedule each month, and show when we last checked each number.
See the schedule
| Signal | Refresh | How |
|---|---|---|
| Ratings and review counts | Monthly | Checked on each site in the first week of the month, dated, with a saved copy |
| Other reviewers’ lists | Monthly | Each list re-checked for its date, its picks and who owns it |
| Pricing and free tiers | Monthly | Every vendor pricing page saved to the Internet Archive. A change flags the review for update |
| Demo videos | Monthly | New demos and reviews pulled and labeled by who made them |
| Rankings | Monthly | Recalculated from the four scores every time we check the data. Nobody adjusts a rank by hand |
If a review goes stale, it says so. Any review more than one quarter past its re-evaluation date is flagged on the page until it is re‑scored.
Right now no link on this site earns us anything. The line under every button to a vendor’s site says whether we earn from it, and nobody can pay for placement, rankings or scores. Details in the advertiser disclosure.
Vendors: help us get your review right
Submit your product or book a demo walkthrough. Both are free, and both make your review more complete.