Home / What should I use? / What’s the best applicant tracking system when you hire your first recruiter?

What’s the best applicant tracking system when you hire your first recruiter?

Answered from public reviews and real prices, for this situation: we’re tracking candidates in spreadsheets and email · 20 to 50 hires a year · 21 to 50 employees · 4 or 5 using it · budget: up to $5,000 · must have a price we can see without a sales call. Change the details

Use JazzHR.

Best match for you

JazzHR3.70 out of 5

The only growing-team system that fits everything you asked for, at 3.70 out of 5.

What you’ll pay$1,000 a yearHero plan, billed yearly.

Your next step: Book a demo of JazzHR with one of your real open roles, and ask for the price in writing first.

Go to JazzHR ↗We earn nothing from this link.Is JazzHR worth it? →
What we ruled out, and why 5 tools
  • Teamtailor No listed price: you have to ask for a quote.
  • Pinpoint No listed price: you have to ask for a quote.
  • BambooHR Its listed price covers up to 25 employees. Above that, you have to ask for a quote.
  • Workable Its listed price covers up to 20 employees. Above that, you have to ask for a quote.
  • Recruitee No listed price: you have to ask for a quote.

What a tool won’t do

A tracking system keeps every candidate in one place, but it won’t speed up a slow decision.

Free from us

What does a hire cost?Cost per hire the way SHRM counts it, next to SHRM’s 2025 medians.

Nobody pays to be featured.

Did this help you decide?

Get this answer by email. If a price or rating changes it, we’ll tell you once.

Made by Stephanie Murray, who also built RepVera. We never share your email with any vendor. Unsubscribe in one click. Privacy

More questions, answered

Job seekers askWhat’s the best free ATS resume checker? →What’s the best resume checker for under $100? →What’s the best free resume builder? →Which resume builder won’t bill you every 4 weeks? →What’s the best free job application tracker? →How do I practice for a job interview? →I get interviews but no offers. Will a tool fix it? →How do I know a job posting is real? →How do I show employers how I work before the interview? →
Hiring teams askWhat’s the best free applicant tracking system for a small business? →What’s the best applicant tracking system for a small team on $2,000 a year? →What’s the best applicant tracking system for a company hiring 50+ people a year? →How do we find good candidates who aren’t applying? →Every interviewer asks something different. Is there a tool for that? →We’re buried in applicants. What should a small team use? →Which applicant tracking systems flag fake candidates? →How do we see how someone works before we interview them? →

How this answer was made

The same rules for every visitor, and none of them can be bought. Every rule, in full

Start with what’s going wrong.

The right tool depends on the problem you’re trying to fix.

Sometimes the answer is no tool.

When software won’t fix it, we say so and point you to what will.

Your answers cross tools off, and they never change a rating.

A tool fits everything you asked for or it’s out, and we show you why. The tools that fit stay in rating order, the same for everyone.

If we can’t confirm it, we don’t recommend it.

A tool we can’t confirm meets your needs can’t be in your answer. It’s listed under what we ruled out, with what we couldn’t confirm.

You get the best match and up to two alternatives.

The best match is the top-rated tool that fits. Each alternative carries one label: best free option, most complete, or Stephanie’s pick, and her pick never changes a score. When none of those applies, the next-highest rated tool that fits is the backup. Every tool we left out is listed with the reason.

Commissions never change the answer.

Whether we earn anything from a tool plays no part in any answer.

Your situation is a little different? Answer a few questions and get your own answer.

Help me choose